Calleary rejects Harris view on dole
The Social Protection Minister clarified his stance in the Dáil following remarks by the Tánaiste regarding long-term unemployment and proposed penalties.
By Gabriel Serrano ·

Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary stated in the Dáil that he does not view the dole as a way of life, distancing his department from recent comments made by Tánaiste Simon Harris. Harris spoke at the Fine Gael ardfheis in Cork, where he described the live register as a safety net rather than a permanent lifestyle. He argued that in a period of full employment, it is unacceptable for individuals to remain on the register for multiple years.
Harris called for penalties to be imposed on people on social welfare who refuse to seek employment. Calleary responded by introducing the Social Welfare Bill, which gives effect to provisions in Budget 2027. The legislation includes a weekly increase of 10 euros in core social welfare benefits. It also introduces a new cost-of-disability payment worth 500 euros. The minister announced that the Christmas bonus, defined as a double social welfare benefit, will be paid in the week starting December 1.
The bill modifies the penalty structure for jobseekers who refuse to engage with mandatory activation services. Currently, these individuals lose 90 euros a week in payments. Under the new legislation, this reduction will increase by 10 euros to a total of 100 euros. Calleary explained that this reduced rate serves as the final step in a process designed to encourage jobseekers to use available employment supports. He noted that the reduction is lifted immediately once a jobseeker resumes engagement with services.
Calleary cited data showing that approximately 58,800 people have either entered or exited the long-term unemployment register over the past 12 months. He described the live register as a flow rather than a stop. The number of people who have been on the live register for a year or more stands at 52,300, which is the lowest level in two years. Of that group, 46,400 will receive a payment.
The minister stated that his department is finalizing the successor to the Pathways to Work strategy. This new plan is due for publication in the coming weeks following a public consultation process that received 430 submissions. Calleary said the strategy will strengthen efforts to support those who are long-term unemployed and face barriers to entering the labour market. He emphasized that while the unemployed have a right to income support, they also have a responsibility to seek employment and engage with state services.
Taoiseach Micheál Martin was asked if Harris had informed him of the proposed penalties. Martin said every party is entitled to put forward ideas, but the programme for government remains the guiding star of government decisions. He described it as an obligation to work with people who have been out of work for more than a year to help them secure employment. Louise O’Reilly, the Sinn Féin social protection spokeswoman, said she was happy to hear the minister’s words distancing him from the Tánaiste’s comments. She noted that it is not unusual for the Fine Gael leader to punch down and that the reasons for unemployment are complicated.
O’Reilly argued that unemployment should not be reduced to a single soundbite just to get a cheer and a guffaw. She emphasized that the complexity of the issue requires a nuanced approach rather than simplistic political statements.






