AdvertiseDonate
Latest20 Labour MPs Pay 9,600 Pounds for Leadership Training
ChicagoMilwaukeeMadisonFort WayneIndianapolisToledoDetroitCincinnati
News Locall · 330 North Wabash Avenue Suite 23rd Floor, Chicago, IL 60611
Politics · Pontiac

Two Federal Suits Challenge 80% Vote on Michigan Utility Spending Ban

Legal actions filed in the Western District of Michigan argue the new law violates free speech rights and unfairly targets regulated energy companies.

By Ricardo Whitaker ·

Illustration for: Two Federal Suits Challenge 80% Vote on Michigan Utility Spending Ban
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Proposal 2, which advanced through the November 2026 general election with more than 80% public support, faces immediate legal opposition in federal court.

Two separate complaints were filed in the Western District of Michigan on November 8, 2026, by distinct groups of challengers. The first action was brought by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy. The second was filed by a coalition of major energy providers, including CMS Energy, Consumers Energy, and DTE.

The measure, known as Michiganders for Money Out of Politics, bans campaign spending by regulated electric and gas utilities. It also prohibits spending by contractors holding government contracts exceeding $250,000 annually. The ban extends to individuals and organizations with substantial connections to those entities.

Under current election law, the new restrictions take effect by December 3, 2026, unless a court issues an order blocking implementation. Both lawsuits argue that the state’s restriction of political spending by these specific groups infringes upon First Amendment rights.

The Mackinac Center’s complaint focuses on the definition of Electioneering Communications and Campaign Expenditures. The think tank argues the statutory language is too broad, creating uncertainty for organizations regarding their donor reporting obligations. The suit states that the center cannot determine which public statements support or attack a candidate under the new vague standards. The organization claims these requirements impose onerous costs and create a chilling effect on protected speech and association.

Patrick J. Wright, vice president of the Mackinac Center Legal Foundation, stated that Michiganders should not face fines or jail for discussing politicians, policy, or elections. Wright said the rules threaten voter access to information and the privacy of supporters. He characterized the lawsuit as a move to protect free speech and prevent partisans from using the law to criminally punish political opponents.

The utility companies’ lawsuit argues the measure constitutes speaker-based viewpoint discrimination. The plaintiffs contend the law fails to meet the threshold for limiting campaign contributions, which is preventing quid pro quo corruption or the appearance thereof. The lawyers for CMS, Consumers, and DTE wrote that there is no evidence of such corruption by Michigan’s utilities, citing the absence of scandals or exchanges of official acts for money. They noted that the ballot measure coalition has regularly opposed the utilities on policy issues.

Samuel Bagenstos, a University of Michigan law professor representing the ballot measure, expressed confidence in the defense. He noted that new campaign finance laws regularly trigger lawsuits, but stated the proposal was drafted with existing judicial decisions in mind. Maura Cowley, the campaign manager for Michiganders for Money Out of Politics, said the suits were expected. She wrote that the corporations bankrolling the opposition had been preparing for litigation since the measure qualified for the ballot. Cowley stated the campaign is prepared to take on any challenge and confident the law will withstand scrutiny.

More Politics · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get News Locall in your inboxLocal news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get News Locall in your inboxLocal news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.