Judge dismisses Harvard lawsuit after DOJ skips procedural step
A federal judge ruled the Justice Department failed to follow required notice procedures before suing Harvard over admissions records, though the dispute over the data remains active.
By Gabriel Serrano ·

U.S. District Judge Myong Joun dismissed a lawsuit brought by the Department of Justice against Harvard University on Monday. The suit challenged the university’s refusal to release specific admissions records that federal officials demanded during a compliance review.
The Justice Department accused Harvard of thwarting its investigation into potential discrimination in admissions. The agency argued that the Ivy League school failed to comply with a federal investigation and asked the court to order the release of the files. Joun rejected this approach, finding that the agency did not take necessary procedural steps before filing the suit.
Joun wrote that before taking enforcement action, the agency must advise the recipient of its failure to comply. The judge also stated that the agency must determine that compliance cannot be secured by voluntary means. The ruling addresses only whether the government satisfied the prerequisites for judicial enforcement at this stage of the legal process.
The judge clarified that the dismissal does not end the dispute over the underlying data. Joun noted that the ruling does not determine whether Harvard discriminated or whether the agencies may lawfully seek applicant-level data. The university may still be required to provide the information in future proceedings.
The Justice Department launched the compliance review in 2025. It requested five years of admissions data for applicants to Harvard’s undergraduate, medical, and law schools. The demand included grades, test scores, essays, extracurricular activities, and admissions outcomes, along with the race and ethnicity of each applicant.
Federal officials stated they need this data to determine if Harvard continues to consider race in admissions decisions. The Supreme Court barred affirmative action in admissions in 2023 after challenges at Harvard and the University of North Carolina. This legal action is part of a wider campaign by the administration against colleges accused of similar practices.
In October, the Justice Department found that the University of California, Los Angeles, law school illegally considered race in admissions. That announcement followed a similar finding against the UCLA medical school. The administration has also accused the UC Berkeley Law School and the medical school at the University of California, San Diego, of illegally discriminating against white and Asian applicants.






