Massachusetts judge sets March retrial date for mother charged with killing three children
Judge William Sullivan scheduled a hearing for November 16 to decide if Lindsay Clancy faces trial again after a September mistrial.
By Gabriel Serrano ·

Judge William Sullivan scheduled a potential retrial for March 2027 after Lindsay Clancy returned to court to challenge the charges of killing her three young children. The hearing took place in Plymouth, Massachusetts, marking the second legal appearance for Clancy since her jury deadlocked in September.
The defense filed a motion to dismiss the case on double jeopardy grounds. Attorney Kevin Reddington argued that the judge should investigate the lone holdout juror, Michael Desronvil. Reddington questioned Desronvil’s use of a cell phone during deliberations and his honesty during jury selection. The judge intervened frequently as the defense publicly named the juror and raised confidential details. Sullivan called the attorneys to a sidebar after prosecutors objected. "Why don’t we all dial this back a little bit," Sullivan said. He did not rule immediately on the dismissal motion.
The trial ended in September when jurors could not agree on a verdict. Clancy has admitted to killing her children in 2023. Her legal team argued she suffered from postpartum psychosis and could not control her behavior. Prosecutors acknowledged her mental health history but maintained she acted deliberately and knew her actions were wrong. They stated they intend to retry the case if the current motion fails.
Defense attorney Martin G. Weinberg contended that Sullivan failed to investigate two notes sent by the jury foreperson. Those notes indicated a juror was not following the rules. Weinberg argued that further questioning could have removed Desronvil and avoided the mistrial. Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague countered that Sullivan struck the right balance. She stated that pressing the foreperson further would have inserted the court’s interpretation into the jury’s private deliberations. "You credited their answers," Sprague told the judge.
Desronvil has said he was certain of Clancy’s guilt but felt ignored. Prosecutors argued that double jeopardy does not bar the state from seeking justice for the three victims. They maintained that the foreperson’s complaint did not allege personal bias or external issues attributable to the dissenting juror. Singling out that juror for investigation would have led to judicial coercion, they said.
Heather O’Connor, an attorney representing Desronvil, disputed the cell phone allegations. She noted that all jurors were allowed to keep their phones and that the defense described scrolling rather than researching case terms. "We are here because Juror Doe did not vote the way that the defense needed," she said. Sullivan also heard arguments on a gag order request. The defense opposes the order, calling it an unconstitutional prior restraint on speech.
Sullivan set the next hearing for November 16. He suggested the retrial could begin in March if the case proceeds.






