Cleveland officials weigh privacy rules for automated license plate readers
Experts and commissioners debated data ownership and surveillance limits at a recent public meeting.
By Gabriel Serrano ·

Brian Ray, director of the Center for Cybersecurity and Privacy Protection at the Cleveland State University College of Law, explained the function of automated license plate readers to a room of city officials on Oct. 22. He told the Cleveland Commission on Black Women and Girls that the primary task of these devices is to convert physical license plates into a machine-readable format. This process allows law enforcement to search for specific vehicles using digital tools.
Ray noted that the technology has evolved beyond simple plate scanning. Modern systems capture vehicle descriptions and details about occupants' clothing. He clarified that while Flock, the vendor providing the system, does not use facial recognition, the technical capability exists. Police departments maintain lists of vehicles involved in crimes, which are scanned randomly to check for historical records. Searches can also target specific dates and times related to incidents.
Piet van Lier, a member of the Community Police Commission, addressed the deployment of these tools in Cleveland. He stated that most Flock cameras in the city are stationary. However, some police vehicle dash cameras also carry Flock capability. Mobile units can be deployed anywhere and are used by various industries, including repossession agencies. These units scan cars in parking lots or while they are driving to check for hits on prior reports.
The commission discussed the privacy implications of these surveillance capabilities. Ray compared ALPRs to other technologies like ShotSpotter, noting that both raise concerns about law enforcement access to enhanced data. He argued that removing Flock entirely would not solve the underlying privacy issues because other technologies would likely replace it. Instead, he advocated for strict controls and policies that ensure transparency and accountability in how the data is used.
Commission Member Taneisha Fair asked about the statistical effectiveness of ALPRs in solving crimes. Ray mentioned a 2026 working paper that examined Flock deployment across 216 agencies. That paper found an 11% decline in vehicle theft after the technology was installed. He described this as an unofficial finding and suggested that a formal cost-benefit study should be part of any new policy documents. Flock also maintains its own statistics for public review.
Lita-Marie Wills raised questions about who owns the data collected by the system. Council Member Stephanie Howse-Jones responded that, to her understanding, the city of Cleveland owns the data. The information is stored for 30 days unless an ongoing investigation requires it to be kept longer. Ray suggested that the city needs greater specificity regarding the justification for surveillance and the requirements for warrants.
Howse-Jones shared results from a non-scientific poll she conducted in her ward. Approximately 35% of respondents indicated they wanted Flock installed in their neighborhood. Van Lier said the commission aims to hear as many voices as possible on the topic. He noted that the Community Police Commission is building an initiative around a resolution that would pause the use of ALPRs until better protections are in place.
Van Lier also discussed the vendor Axon, which provides other surveillance technologies like FUSUS and Gravity. He expressed concern that Gravity combines all of Axon's surveillance tools into one platform, creating a large privacy consideration. The commission is working collaboratively with the police to establish policies that balance crime reduction with community safety. CPC holds the final decision on police policy within the city, though it operates in partnership with law enforcement.
The meeting adjourned at 6:36 p.m. on Oct. 22. The next session is scheduled for Monday, Nov. 18, at 5 p.m. It will be held in City Hall Room 514 and is available via Microsoft Teams for those who cannot attend in person.






