Cleveland Police Survey Delays Frustrate Council
A required biennial community assessment has not been completed since 2018, with city officials citing concurrent research to justify the hold.
By Ricardo Whitaker ·

The required biennial survey of Cleveland residents regarding their perceptions of the police has not been completed since 2018. Paragraph 361 of the 2015 consent decree mandates that the court-appointed monitor and the city conduct a reliable, comprehensive, and representative survey every two years. The most recent completed instrument dates to 2018, leaving a gap of nearly eight years in the formal data collection process.
Monitor Christine Cole told City Council that the 2020 and 2021 cycles were interrupted by the pandemic and a mayoral election. She stated she had no explanation for why the survey did not occur in 2022 or 2023. Cole noted that the monitor is ready to proceed but requires the city’s approval of a request for proposals, as the city funds the effort. The Police Accountability Team has asked the monitor to postpone the new survey to avoid survey fatigue and to align with their own ongoing research.
Councilmember Stephanie Howse-Jones raised the issue at consecutive hearings in May and November. She expressed frustration that the city and the Department of Justice sought release from the decree earlier this year without first soliciting public input. Howse-Jones criticized the lack of engagement, stating, "How are all these people saying, 'We want to get out it?' But we ain't never ask the people their opinions." The court rejected the city's request for release from the decree.
Leigh Anderson, head of the Police Accountability Team, provided an update during a recent council meeting. Anderson reported that researchers from Kent State University have attended 45 community events and completed 355 individual surveys. The team has met with the Cleveland Division of Police training unit to integrate resident feedback into current instruction. Anderson wrote in a September memo that the sequencing supports a more informed and defensible survey process, aiming to ensure the final instrument reflects current information needs.
The city has not released the results of the Kent State research or detailed the questions asked of the 355 participants. In the last completed survey in 2018, 44% of respondents believed the police treated all races equally, while only 25% felt officers treated Black people the same as others. Nearly 80% of white adults rated the department positively in that year, compared to 49% of Black residents.
Cole told council that the monitor was prepared to begin the new survey after the May hearing but faced resistance from the city. She stated, "Multiple times, we were ready to go. And then the city asked us to postpone due to survey fatigue." Cole emphasized that the city must approve the funding and the scope of the study.
Howse-Jones concluded the November meeting by proposing a budget amendment. She requested $100,000 for the coming fiscal year specifically to fund the community survey. The council has not yet voted on the addition.






