Carney Sees Path to Tariff Relief After US Midterm Shift
Newly elected Democrats vow to curb duties on Canada, but Trump retains veto power over legislation.
By Adrian Romano ·

The outcome of the November 3 US midterm elections has altered the political environment for Canada-US trade talks. Democratic candidates won key seats in states where tariff costs affected local economies. Ontario Premier Doug Ford called the result a victory for Canada on Wednesday. He expressed delight at the shift in American politics.
Voters in several states punished incumbents who supported President Donald Trump’s tariff policies. In Maine, Democrat Troy Jackson defeated Republican Senator Susan Collins after she clashed with the White House over duties on road salt and refrigeration equipment. In Michigan, Democrat Abdul El-Sayed beat Republican Mike Rogers. The National Taxpayers Union Foundation links Trump's 25% tariffs on non-US vehicles to layoffs in Ontario and higher household costs in Michigan.
Newly elected officials have voiced opposition to the levies. Senator-elect Sherrod Brown from Ohio defeated Jon Husted. Brown labeled the tariffs a disaster and pledged to reduce them. Democratic leaders Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries have pushed to rein in duties on Canada in recent months. Their increased influence may strengthen their ability to negotiate.
However, the practical impact of this shift faces hurdles. Trump enacted most tariffs through executive orders, bypassing congressional approval. During a Tuesday night interview on Fox News, Trump reaffirmed his ability to veto bills passed by Congress. Some Democratic lawmakers have historically supported certain tariffs to protect American manufacturing, meaning not all duties will be removed automatically.
Current tariffs affect sectors including autos, steel, aluminum, and forestry. After trade talks collapsed in August, the US imposed an additional 50% tariff on $20 billion worth of Canadian goods. This includes dairy and cosmetics. The US also banned imports of motorcycles, whey protein, and alcohol. Canada retaliated with its own 50% dollar-for-dollar tariffs. Most provinces banned the sale of US alcohol.
Negotiations have resumed following the political shift. Prime Minister Mark Carney noted on Tuesday that US negotiators have been asking for less and offering more in recent discussions. Just before the vote, Trump told reporters that a trade deal was very close after speaking with Carney. Carney has struck an optimistic tone recently, though he told Politico last month that he is prepared to wait for a new American president if necessary to reach a comprehensive agreement.
US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer previously expressed ambitions to establish interim deals with Canada and Mexico regarding the North American Free Trade Agreement. Known as USMCA in the US and CUSMA in Canada, these deals aim to conclude before the end of the year. Canada does not intend to speculate on American strategy, according to Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc.
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre acknowledged that nobody controls Trump. He argued that the election results demonstrate Canada has massive leverage due to the unpopularity of the tariffs. This goodwill should be used to pressure for tariff-free trade. Colin Robertson, a fellow at the Canadian Global Affairs Institute, suggested Trump may feel increased pressure to sign a deal now that voter frustration is evident. Robertson noted that Canada has an ideal window between now and January, when new Democratic lawmakers are sworn in, to finalize a deal. After that, Trump may become distracted by investigations into his family and administration.






