Senate Race: Muslim identity cost Abdul El-Sayed five points
New polling data reveals a substantial voting penalty for the Democrat among likely voters, despite strong support from Arab and Muslim communities.
By Adrian Romano ·

Democrat Abdul El-Sayed won a U.S. Senate seat in Michigan but paid a measurable price for his religion in the final weeks of the campaign. According to pre-election data from the University of Chicago's NORC Center, El-Sayed trailed other Democrats at the top of the ticket by approximately five points. Nura Sediqe, an assistant professor of political science at Michigan State University, analyzed the results and found that his identity as a Muslim was the primary factor driving this deficit relative to his party colleagues.
Sediqe noted that while 97% of polled Muslim voters indicated they would support El-Sayed, a larger segment of the electorate hesitated. A Michigan State University survey conducted with YouGov in the first two weeks of October asked likely voters if they would support a Muslim candidate. Thirty-nine percent said they would not. Sediqe observed that this reluctance fell along partisan lines, with many in the Republican camp influenced by campaign ads that emphasized anti-Muslim sentiment. The data suggests that fear of identity politics created a headwind that El-Sayed had to overcome with strong economic messaging.
The campaign strategy focused on affordability, health care, and removing money from politics rather than identity. Sediqe argued that this approach resonated with everyday citizens who were leaving the Republican Party due to economic concerns. The mobilization effort, particularly among young voters, helped propel the unlikely candidate past established Democratic preferences. This focus on domestic issues allowed El-Sayed to counter the narrative of fear that dominated some advertisements.
Arab and Muslim communities in Michigan have deep roots in the state, particularly in Southeast Michigan where many families have worked in the auto industry for generations. These voters have held local offices, including several mayoralties, and have maintained consistent policy priorities focused on jobs, health care, and the economy. The only major divergence in recent voting patterns occurred in 2024, when the issue of Palestine and foreign policy influenced the ballot choices of some Arab American voters.
The 2024 election marked a split in the Arab American voting bloc. Arab Muslims largely supported Kamala Harris or third-party candidates, while Arab Christians voted for Donald Trump. In the current cycle, this split persisted but with variations. Pre-election polling showed that while 98% of Arab Muslim voters supported El-Sayed, only 41% of Arab Christian voters did. Some Arab Christian voters supported Governor-elect Jocelyn Benson but not El-Sayed, while others remained with the Republican Party. Sediqe noted that Arab Christians were the anomaly in the 2024 cycle and continued to show distinct policy preferences compared to other Arab American groups in the state.
The victory for El-Sayed represents the first time many Middle Eastern and North African voters in Michigan had the chance to cast a statewide ballot for a candidate who shared their cultural background. The engagement of this demographic was driven by a desire for representation and a focus on economic stability. The results confirm that while identity played a role in the margin of victory, the core issues of cost of living and healthcare remained the deciding factors for the majority of the electorate.






