AdvertiseDonate
Latest20 Labour MPs Pay 9,600 Pounds for Leadership Training
ChicagoMilwaukeeMadisonFort WayneIndianapolisToledoDetroitCincinnati
News Locall · 330 North Wabash Avenue Suite 23rd Floor, Chicago, IL 60611
Business · Pasadena

Manhattan courts: Brave Software sells stolen news to AI firms

Publishers claim the browser maker scrapes billions of pages to bypass paywalls and train competitors' models.

By Ricardo Whitaker ·

Illustration for: Manhattan courts: Brave Software sells stolen news to AI firms
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Newsrooms in New York, Chicago, and Orlando have taken legal action against a Silicon Valley browser maker. The Daily News, The New York Times, and their affiliated papers filed federal lawsuits in Manhattan on Monday. The suits accuse Brave Software of using automated tools to copy exclusive stories from their websites. The publishers claim Brave then resold that content to major artificial intelligence companies.

The filings describe the process as a commercial pipeline for digital journalism. A complaint in Manhattan federal court states that Brave acts as a supplier and distributor of copyrighted material. The document calls the company a back door that allows users and AI developers to access paywalled articles. It argues that Brave functions like a fence selling stolen goods to third parties who build their businesses on that content.

The lawsuit details how Brave gathered the material. It claims the company crawled and copied more than 30 billion webpages without identifying itself to the site owners. The publishers say Brave provided no mechanism for those owners to block the crawler. The suit alleges the company sold copies of this content to third parties for use in training AI models and generating responses to user queries.

The legal action highlights the conflict between browser features and paywalls. Paywalls serve as a primary revenue stream for news organizations producing original reporting. Frank Pine, executive editor at Tribune Publishing and MediaNews Group, noted that these barriers are critical for competing in the current news environment. The suits assert that Brave's browser provides free access to this protected content, effectively stripping the value of the paywall.

The complaint includes specific examples of the software's behavior. One instance involved a user asking the AI feature, known as Ask Brave, for articles from The News published that day. The chatbot listed the titles of 35 paywalled stories and offered to pull the full text for any of them. In another example, a user asked about Orlando politics. The bot identified stories from the Orlando Sentinel and, after further prompting, reproduced text verbatim and closely paraphrased coverage of the governor's race.

The publishers have grouped this case with other major AI litigation. The same group of newspapers is also suing OpenAI and Microsoft for similar conduct. This adds to a growing number of cases across the country where copyright owners are challenging tech giants over the use of their content for model training. The lawsuits list five legal claims, alleging direct, contributory, and vicarious copyright infringement.

Steven Lieberman, an attorney for The News and its sister papers, said the AI industry is trying to avoid direct theft. He stated that Brave is selling a back door to journalism that companies know they do not have a right to. Lieberman argued that buying stolen goods secondhand does not make them legitimate. He said Brave must be held responsible for laundering pirated reporting for the AI sector.

In a statement, Pine said the software company made a mockery of intellectual property laws. He said Brave pillages the internet and resells its gains to buyers. Pine added that the company touts its privacy protection for customers while attempting to delete evidence of its actions under a Zero Data Retention policy.

Brave Software, Inc., did not respond to a request for comment on Monday. The News also reached out to Anthropic and other AI companies accused of buying the content. Those companies are not named as defendants in the lawsuits filed this week.

More Business · Watch Your Wallet · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get News Locall in your inboxLocal news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get News Locall in your inboxLocal news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.