AdvertiseDonate
Latest20 Labour MPs Pay 9,600 Pounds for Leadership Training
ChicagoMilwaukeeMadisonFort WayneIndianapolisToledoDetroitCincinnati
News Locall · 330 North Wabash Avenue Suite 23rd Floor, Chicago, IL 60611
News · Wisconsin

Madison Council: Signal Group Chat Raises Questions on Public Records

Eight current and former council members used a secure messaging app with disappearing messages for personal coordination, leaving journalists unable to verify if city business was discussed.

By Ricardo Whitaker ·

Illustration for: Madison Council: Signal Group Chat Raises Questions on Public Records
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A group chat on the Signal messaging app has created a gap in public oversight for the Madison Common Council. Eight of the council's 20 current members participated in this private channel, which also included four former members for a total of twelve users. The core issue is not the social nature of the conversations, but the technical architecture of the app that prevents outside verification of its contents.

Signal is designed for privacy. The nonprofit that built the app does not store messages on a central server once they are deleted. It also features an optional setting that automatically erases messages after a user-defined time. While journalists use this tool to protect whistleblowers and organizers use it to coordinate protests, its use by elected officials complicates the standard right-to-know process.

The timeline of the chat spans several years. Journalist Robert Chappell first became aware of the group a few months ago. He reviewed screenshots that confirmed the participation of the eight sitting council members. The member who created the group initially warned against discussing city business and requested that the disappearing messages setting be turned off. However, over an 18 month period, several members adjusted the timer. They set messages to delete after one day or one week, proving they were familiar with the feature.

Chappell asked the participants to confirm the content of the chats. They stated they used the group for social planning, sharing news articles, vacation photos, and recipes. They insisted no city business was discussed. Because Signal deletes messages permanently, no records custodian holds the data. This differs from standard email or text messages, which remain on a server and can be subpoenaed by a court if a dispute arises.

The situation leaves the public in a position of forced trust. With email, a requester can challenge a custodian's decision to withhold records in court. A judge can then inspect the device or server. With Signal, if a message is gone, it is gone. The press has no mechanism to compel the release of data that no longer exists. The council members are technically compliant with the law regarding strictly personal communications, but they are using a tool that obscures the line between private and public.

The next step in this oversight process is the ongoing review of the council's internal communications. Chappell and the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council are monitoring how the council handles similar platforms in the future. The council members have maintained their position that the chats were personal, but the technical ability to hide messages has permanently altered the evidentiary landscape for local government accountability.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get News Locall in your inboxLocal news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Related stories

Get News Locall in your inboxLocal news, all in one place. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.