Attack ads feature El-Sayed over 9/11 wreckage as Michigan religious groups split
Rabbis and Muslim leaders in Michigan are criticizing Senate campaign rhetoric that they say targets their communities with stereotypes and divisive imagery.
By Gabriel Serrano ·

Democratic U.S. Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed appears superimposed over the wreckage from the September 11, 2001, attacks in a new Republican attack ad. The image has fueled fears among Michigan’s Muslim and Jewish communities that the election cycle is becoming a referendum on religious identity. There is no record of El-Sayed supporting terrorism.
The controversy erupted following a Tuesday event at a children’s play space in Canton. Democratic women, including Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib, gathered to address what they described as a rise in dehumanizing rhetoric. Tlaib noted that the constant barrage of negative ads has become a daily reality for her family. She said she often turns off the radio or changes the television channel to avoid seeing the imagery while trying to watch sports or series.
Tlaib blamed President Donald Trump for creating an environment that mirrors the early days of his first term in 2016 and 2017. She described the current climate as one where immigrant and Muslim-American communities face increased scrutiny. Many attendees at the event identified as mothers who fear the political attacks will bleed into their children’s lives. Tlaib emphasized that the group came together to protect their kids and push back against the ugliness of the year.
The tension extends to political strategy. Business owner Sara Khan criticized politicians for treating her community as a campaign prop. She argued that respect for these communities should not begin only when votes are needed and end when they are secured. Khan stated that meeting with a few community members does not represent the entire group. This sentiment reflects a broader frustration with politicians who win in cities with heavy Muslim populations, such as Dearborn and Hamtramck, without maintaining consistent support.
At a separate press conference earlier Tuesday, a group of rabbis called for more measured language in the Senate race. The group, Nonnegotiable Michigan, expressed concern that criticisms of Israel have waded into antisemitism. They accused the progressive organization Rebellion PAC of using anti-Jewish stereotypes in an ad portraying Jews as bloodthirsty. The ad features a couple at a grocery store who claim they cannot afford items because U.S. aid to Israel goes toward killing Palestinians.
The El-Sayed campaign stated it was not affiliated with Rebellion PAC or the advertisement. Campaign officials said their focus is on fighting high costs driven by President Trump’s agenda. However, Rabbi Aaron Starr of Congregation Shaarey Zedek in Southfield argued that El-Sayed has not done enough to denounce the ad. Starr said the candidate is merely distancing himself rather than discrediting the commercial.
Starr noted that Nonnegotiable Michigan was founded to call out extremism within the Democratic Party, given the multigenerational support Jews have shown for the party. He expressed hope that multigenerational Republicans would also call out extremism in their own party. The rabbis acknowledged feeling politically homeless when considering support for Republican nominee Mike Rogers from figures they view as openly racist.
Counter-currents exist within the Jewish community. A group called Michigan Jews for Democracy is circulating a letter urging Jewish Democrats to support the El-Sayed campaign. This division highlights the complex dynamics in Michigan elections, where minority groups often find themselves split by party lines and cultural issues. School principal Yvonne Lewis suggested that national leaders are exploiting pain points to divide Americans. She believes the strategy of separation and division is failing because many people have positive experiences with one another.
The next scheduled step involves continued campaigning and potential responses from both sides to the new advertisements. The El-Sayed campaign plans to keep its focus on economic issues, while the Nonnegotiable group will continue to monitor the race for language they view as threatening to Jewish safety.






