Theological Perspective: God's Power Defined by Limitation
A clergy reflection argues that divine love is inherently non-controlling, suggesting God works through invitation rather than force.
By Adrian Romano ·

A new clergy reflection challenges the traditional understanding of divine power, proposing that God does not intervene in human tragedy because love, by its nature, does not coerce. The piece, published in the Brainerd Dispatch, suggests that the common question of why God allows suffering may be framed incorrectly. Instead of asking why God does not stop pain, the reflection invites readers to consider that God may be unable to control outcomes in the way people often expect.
The author, a 9-year-old observer in the fall of 1957, describes watching his father, a Merchant Marine First Mate, collapse from a seizure on their screened porch. He recalls praying for his father's life, only to lose him six years later. That experience led to a lifelong question about why God did not heal his dad, a question that forms the basis of the current reflection.
The author critiques familiar religious responses such as the idea that God has a mysterious plan or that everything happens for a reason. He argues that these answers can imply that suffering serves a divine purpose or that God wills tragedy. The reflection offers an alternative view: God’s power is not the power to command or compel, but the power to abide, nudge, and inspire.
Citing theologian Thomas Jay Oord, the piece outlines a specific theological position. Oord argues that because God’s nature is love, God cannot unilaterally determine human choices or suspend the laws of nature. This means God cannot force compassion or guarantee healing for every illness. The author emphasizes that this limitation does not mean God is absent, but rather that God is involved through invitation rather than domination.
The reflection connects this theology to the life of Jesus, who demonstrated love through washing feet and welcoming outsiders rather than through military power. On the cross, the author notes, love appears as vulnerability rather than domination. This perspective shifts the focus from divine control to divine presence. Pain does not eliminate God's presence, but God's presence does not eliminate pain.
The author describes divine action as a sacred nudge, such as compassion interrupting indifference or hope emerging from despair. God nudges people toward generosity, reconciliation, and justice, but humans retain the ability to resist. The future remains open, and love does not always prevail immediately. This understanding redefines prayer not as a tool to control God, but as a way to open oneself to the divine presence already at work.
According to the reflection, when people pray for peace, healing, or justice, they become attentive to practicing those things in their own lives. Prayer changes a person's willingness to participate in love rather than changing God's willingness to love. Hope is described not as certainty of a specific outcome, but as trust that possibilities for love remain even in difficult circumstances. These possibilities include small acts like sitting beside a sick person or welcoming those who are excluded.
The reflection concludes by asking if God would be less worthy of faith if divine power is defined by compassion and relationship rather than domination. It suggests that the central question for believers is no longer why God does not do something, but what God is inviting people to do together. The piece ends with the assertion that God abides, nudges, accompanies, and loves.






