Prosecutors charge West Allis husband with first-degree intentional homicide
Benjamin Carpenter faces charges in the 2024 death of his wife, Erica, after claiming she fell while he carried her up basement stairs.
By Gabriel Serrano ·

A West Allis man was charged on Tuesday with first-degree intentional homicide in the death of his wife. Benjamin Carpenter, 34, was arrested on November 17, 2026, after prosecutors filed a criminal complaint alleging he planned and caused Erica Carpenter’s death.
The incident occurred on October 13, 2024, when West Allis police responded to the couple’s home near South 95th and West Dakota streets around 10:30 p.m. Officers were dispatched following a request for a welfare check. At the scene, Benjamin Carpenter told investigators that he and his wife were doing laundry in the basement. He stated that Erica collapsed, hitting her head against the floor what he described as mildly hard.
Carpenter claimed that while carrying his wife up the basement stairs, he slipped. Both fell to the bottom of the staircase, where Erica struck her head against a cinder block wall. She was transported to the hospital but later died from her injuries. Police said the investigation began with that initial welfare check request and has now found probable cause that the death was premeditated.
The criminal complaint filed on November 17 contrasts the initial account with the prosecution’s theory that Benjamin Carpenter planned the killing. He was taken into custody the same day the complaint was filed. Erica A. Carpenter was 32 years old at the time of her death.
West Allis police are asking anyone with information about the death to contact the department at 414-302-8000. The case will proceed through the Milwaukee County circuit court system, where a preliminary hearing is expected to be scheduled in the coming weeks.






