Mount Greenwood Hosts Halloween Pop-Up for Former Grocer Don Cosentino
Residents will gather Saturday to honor the 93-year-old former butcher and his late wife, who ran a local staple for 35 years.
By Gabriel Serrano ·

Don Cosentino will return to the corner of 10653 S. Homan Ave. on Saturday to mark Halloween. The 93-year-old former butcher will join family members and the Mount Greenwood Historical Committee for a pop-up shop from 4 to 6 p.m. outside the site where he once ran his grocery store. The event serves as a tribute to a business that closed nearly 20 years ago.
The original Don’s Finer Foods opened in 1972. It operated for 35 years before closing its doors in 2007. During that time, it served as a primary source for groceries, cut-to-order meats, and candy for the neighborhood. The building now houses a residence, but the community remembers it as a central hub for daily life.
Margaret Schroeder, president of the Mount Greenwood Historical Committee, organized the event to reconnect past customers with the retired shop owner. She noted that many residents still ask about Cosentino’s well-being. “People say all the time, ‘Where’s Don? How has he been?’ The kids used to stop there all the time for candy, so I thought we’d have him come on Halloween,” Schroeder said. Her family will hand out sweets while wearing the white apron and Hanes T-shirt Cosentino wore for decades.
The store was a family operation founded by Cosentino and his late wife, Marie. Geena Abbott, Cosentino’s granddaughter, explained that relatives worked alongside him from a young age. “Every family member all played a part. You worked there from the time you were little until you had a job of your own, and even then a little bit after,” Abbott said. The family prepared products in-house, including sausage and ground beef, with minimal outside help.
Marie Cosentino, who died in October 2012, handled much of the cooking behind the scenes. Donna Dunleavy, Cosentino’s daughter, recalled how the shop prepared corned beef for local residents and St. Christina School around St. Patrick’s Day. Abbott described her grandfather as a person who enjoyed interacting with customers and learning their names. The store’s role extended beyond commerce, embedding itself in the daily routines of the Mount Greenwood community.
Saturday’s gathering also honors Russ Schroeder, a 95-year-old resident who grew up on the 10600 block of South Homan Avenue. The Schroeder family has lived on that block for a century. The historical committee aims to preserve these local narratives through community events like the upcoming Halloween pop-up.
The event takes place this Saturday. The site of the former grocery store is now a private home. Cosentino’s family will be present to distribute candy and greet attendees. The Historical Committee will lead the celebration to recognize the contributions of both Cosentino and the Schroeder family to the neighborhood’s history.






