Devils Prioritize Win Probability Over Hellebuyck's Return to Winnipeg
General Manager Sunny Mehta cited a drop in expected win probability as the reason the 33-year-old goaltender will not face his former team at Canada Life Centre.
By Gabriel Serrano ·

The New Jersey Devils have decided against starting Connor Hellebuyck in their Tuesday matchup against the Winnipeg Jets, a choice that removes the star goaltender from his first return to Canada Life Centre since demanding a trade.
The decision came shortly after the Devils defeated the Toronto Maple Leafs 4-0 on Sunday. Hellebuyck recorded a shutout in that game, stopping 23 shots. The team announced the lineup change immediately following the final buzzer in Toronto.
General Manager Sunny Mehta explained the rationale in a written statement released by the club. Mehta noted that the organization debated the issue at length. He stated that playing the game would potentially reduce the team's expected win probability, a metric the front office prioritized over individual sentiment.
Hellebuyck, 33, expressed disappointment upon learning of the decision. He spoke to reporters in the visitors' locker room at Scotiabank Arena on Sunday night. The goaltender said he felt a duty to play but accepted the organizational choice. He described the situation as complex and indicated he would share more details at a media availability before the game.
The move ends a 11-season tenure for Hellebuyck in Winnipeg. The Jets traded him to New Jersey on Oct. 23. They received forward Dawson Mercer, goaltender Nico Daws, and a second-round pick in the 2029 NHL draft in exchange. Hellebuyck had five years remaining on a seven-year contract worth US$59.1 million when he requested the deal.
Since joining New Jersey, Hellebuyck has started five games. He holds a 5-0-0 record with a .913 save percentage and a 1.96 goals-against average. The Devils have won nine of their last 10 games. Head coach Sheldon Keefe said the team had to explain the decision to Hellebuyck, who felt it was his responsibility to play.
Hellebuyck entered the 2026 season after leading the United States to an Olympic gold medal. He made 41 saves in the final against Canada at the Milan Cortina Games. In his regular season career with Winnipeg, he compiled a 349-208-55 record with a .916 save percentage and 45 shutouts. He also reached the 2018 Western Conference final.
The goaltender said he does not know how fans in Manitoba will react to his absence from the ice. He acknowledged a sour taste in the city but said he would choose to remember the community and his cherished moments there. He described the decision to leave as one that no one has fully nailed down due to the many factors involved.






