Democrats poised to push National Popular Vote compact past 270 threshold
Midterm wins in five battleground states could give the interstate agreement the electoral votes needed to override the Electoral College.
By Adrian Romano ·

Democratic control of Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada, and Wisconsin creates the conditions for the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact to reach the 270 electoral vote threshold required to activate. This milestone would allow the compact to award all participating states' electoral votes to the winner of the national popular vote, bypassing the traditional Electoral College system. The move relies on the incoming state legislatures and governors in these five states formally signing the interstate agreement. Currently, the compact holds 222 electoral votes from 18 states and the District of Columbia. The five newly Democratic-led states add 61 more votes. If at least four of these states join the existing members, the total will exceed the necessary 270.
Proponents believe this development places the popular vote initiative within reach for the 2028 presidential election. Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to the National Popular Vote group, told NPR that he has never been more confident that 63% of American voters can secure their preference in the next election. He referenced Pew Research Center polling to support this claim. No Republican-led states have joined the compact to date, and the party remains divided on the issue. The compact is legally dormant until the 270-electoral-vote mark is met.
Political hesitation exists among key state leaders despite the mathematical possibility. Democratic Governor Katie Hobbs of Arizona, who previously supported the measure, has not recently commented on whether her state will sign on. Her office did not respond to inquiries from NPR before publication. Governors in Pennsylvania and Nevada have indicated openness to signing legislation, while others have yet to weigh in. State leaders face a difficult calculation. These five states are traditional presidential battlegrounds. Joining the compact would reduce their individual influence in future elections. Leaders must decide if they want to be the tipping point for a movement that changes how the United States selects its president.
Legal scholars warn that the compact may face constitutional challenges. The Compact Clause of the Constitution states that no state shall enter into an agreement with another state without the consent of Congress, unless the state is actually invaded or in imminent danger. Norman Miller, a constitutional law professor at Willamette University, noted that this clause creates a potential legal hurdle. He also identified practical issues with the decentralized nature of American elections. States currently decide independently who can vote and how votes are tabulated. Miller argued that forcing electors in one state to vote based on national tallies could create tension among the 51 separate election administrators.
John Koza, chairman of National Popular Vote, countered that the compact relies on existing state and federal laws. He told NPR that the system does not require a new centralized bureaucracy or a presidentially appointed commission. According to Koza, current law already provides for a certified vote count from each state. The compact simply requires adding those certified numbers together. Koza argued that this method avoids the manipulation risks associated with a national election authority.
Miller maintains that the most robust solution remains a constitutional amendment under Article 5. He believes that if the goal is to permanently replace the Electoral College, the process must be fulsome to address all legal and practical difficulties. A similar effort to pass an amendment failed in 1969. Few amendments have come close to passing in recent history. Rosenstiel argued that groups like his seek creative solutions because most Americans view the current system as flawed. He stated that a national popular vote would force candidates to appeal to the entire country rather than just battleground state voters. Rosenstiel concluded that a system where every citizen feels their vote matters requires this specific reform.
The compact’s success depends on state legislatures passing enabling legislation and governors signing it. The five states in question are Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada, and Wisconsin. Their combined electoral vote count is 61. The current total of 222 votes must reach 270 for the mechanism to trigger. The next major test is whether these state leaders will prioritize the national agreement over their local electoral influence in the lead-up to 2028.






